Permits, Power, and Who Gets to Decide

The Street Vendor Project’s victory deserves attention not only for what changed in policy, but for what it reveals about leadership over time. The outcome reflects years of choices about power, accountability, and whose experience was treated as authoritative. Those choices matter more than any single campaign moment.

I first joined the Street Vendor Project (SVP) advisory board in 2014 and served for three years. During that period, and in the years that followed, my ability to support the work was shaped by the institutions I worked within and alongside, including wealthy, predominantly white organizations with resources and access. Whatever their shortcomings, they created room for me to keep SVP’s priorities present in my roles through ongoing campaign support, pro bono analysis, strategic conversations, and policy work tied to raising the cap on vending permits. Those positions also allowed me to support what became Environmental Justice For Vendors By Vendors, grounded in vendors naming their own needs and solutions in the face of bad-faith “climate” and “clean streets” arguments used by business improvement districts, developers, and some brick-and-mortar interests to push eviction by another name.

I eventually chose to step off the advisory board because of growing inconsistencies between SVP’s stated values and how leadership was operating at the time. I did not leave because the mission mattered less. I left because misalignment was becoming codified, and I was not willing to lend my name or energy to leadership practices that weakened the work and harmed the people most affected by it. In my coaching practice, this is a consistent through line: alignment requires boundaries, even when you stay committed to the outcome.

What stands out, looking back, is how SVP continued to evolve after that period. The organization demonstrated a willingness to confront the limits of leadership models that were not directly accountable to street vendors themselves. Earlier approaches, while often well intentioned and professionally fluent, created distance from lived experience and, at times, caused harm to staff and vendors alike. SVP ultimately moved toward a leadership orientation that centered vendors not as symbols or spokespeople, but as decision makers with real authority over strategy and priorities.

That shift mattered. It changed how problems were defined and which solutions were pursued. It also clarified what kind of leadership the work actually required. Street vending in New York City was never only a regulatory issue. It has always been shaped by xenophobia, the criminalization of poverty, and fear of immigrant economic autonomy. Addressing that reality required leadership willing to say so plainly and act accordingly.

SVP also refused to fight on a single front. Street level organizing continued. Legislative and policy advocacy continued. Legal analysis deepened. Environmental justice concerns surfaced through vendors themselves, not as an add on, but as central to the work. This was a practical reading of how power operates. Harm was produced through enforcement, law, public space design, and narrative at the same time. Strategy had to meet that complexity.

The long fight over permits and licenses captures this clearly. For years, New York City capped the number of vending permits while continuing to issue licenses. A license establishes eligibility. A permit allows someone to vend legally in public space. The gap between the two created artificial scarcity by design. Thousands of licensed vendors were locked out of legal work and exposed to fines, confiscation, and harassment. This structure did not emerge by accident. It functioned as a containment mechanism with predictable racial and economic consequences.

SVP stayed focused on that underlying structure even when it was slow, technical, and politically inconvenient. That persistence required leadership grounded in lived experience and supported by analysis. It also required patience, discipline, and a refusal to settle for surface level fixes.

For me, this victory connects directly to the coaching work I do now with StrivEquity Consulting LLC. I spend much of my time with leaders who feel pressure to stay inside systems that reward comfort, familiarity, and professional polish, even when those systems undermine their stated values. The SVP story offers a reminder that equity work advances when organizations are willing to change who holds power, how decisions are made, and what accountability actually looks like.

This win belongs to street vendors. The leadership lessons travel beyond this moment. Progress came because people stayed with the work, named misalignment when it appeared, set boundaries when necessary, and continued pushing for structures that reflected the dignity and agency of those most impacted. That combination, sustained over time, is what made this outcome possible.

Congratulations to the Street Vendor Project and, most importantly, to the vendors who refused to accept a system designed to sideline them.

Forty seven years is not a policy delay. It is a structural choice. This win came because people organized, analyzed, pushed, recalibrated, and kept going.

If you care about what equitable economic policy looks like in practice, support the Street Vendor Project here: https://www.streetvendor.org/donate

Reform is now law. Power building continues.

David DeVaughn grounds his coaching and strategy work in a simple conviction: that leaders who are most burdened by inequity deserve the most rigorous, caring, and honest support available. As Founder and Managing Principal of StrivEquity Consulting LLC, he works at the intersection of personal transformation and institutional change, coaching and strategy with leaders who seek to close the gap between who they are and how they lead. Through the Equity-Responsive Leadership (ERL) model, David centers identity, power, and accountability as the operating logic of effective leadership. His strategy practice spans city government, public health, philanthropy, and national nonprofits, where he has consistently helped teams move from compliance to genuine cultural responsiveness. David is an ICF Professional Certified Coach (PCC), an NYC & NYS MBE-certified firm founder, and a National Urban Fellow with nearly 20 years of experience across policy, workforce development, and equity-centered capacity building.

Credits – LinkedIn

More Blog Posts

Picture7
brett-jordan-unsplash
1740588331518
Picture9