New York City's Bike Lanes Are Part of Its Food Supply Chain. The Streets Plan Should Say So.

New York City has spent nearly two decades building out its bike lane network, and in the process, it has overlooked a significant part of the city’s food supply chain: groceries, takeout, and goods now reach millions of New Yorkers through lanes still designed as if they were only for recreation or low-cost transit. The city’s planning has not kept pace with how much food now moves through them. As the Mamdani administration writes the next five-year Streets Plan, due December 1, 2026, it has an opportunity to treat bike lanes as essential food, labor, and transportation infrastructure for the app-based workers who depend on them most.

Local Law 195 of 2019 requires the city’s Department of Transportation (DOT) to publish its Streets Plan every five years: a blueprint that commits the city to specific, measurable street changes, such as miles of protected bike and bus lanes, redesigned intersections, and accessible pedestrian signals. It is a binding plan with targets the city is legally obligated to meet. The next plan will shape how the city builds its streets through 2031.

The trouble, says Jerome Nathaniel, a food justice advocate and non-voting member of Brooklyn Community Board 3 who studies urban planning at the Pratt Institute, is that the city plans each leg separately. It rarely treats the wholesalers who stock the corner store, the freight that supplies the restaurant, and the bike lane that carries the order as one system. By the time food reaches the last mile, the lane is often too narrow to carry more than a single app-based worker’s orders at a time.

This means the next Streets Plan is a chance to decide whether the city will recognize bike lanes as part of its food system, design them for the workers who move that system, and resolve the conflicts that now place deliveristas, vendors, pedestrians, cyclists, and freight vehicles in competition for the same narrow space.

A Workplace Built Into Traffic

The bike lane is the last stretch of a food system that runs across the whole city. Food arrives in New York in bulk through terminals in the Bronx and Brooklyn, then travels by truck or barge from neighborhood to neighborhood. By the time it reaches the bike lane, the system has shifted to last-mile delivery: groceries, prepared meals, and goods moving one order at a time toward the door.

For delivery workers, the lane is a job site. The city’s Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP) counts more than 80,000 delivery workers, a workforce large enough that bike-lane safety is also workplace safety. “For Los Deliveristas Unidos [LDU], bike lanes are not just transportation infrastructure: they are part of the city’s essential economic and food infrastructure,” said Gabriel Montero, Development and Communications Director of the Workers Justice Project, which organizes the coalition. Workers experience every gap in the infrastructure as a workplace hazard. That danger is measurable: DCWP has found that delivery workers who rely on e-bikes and mopeds are killed on the job at roughly five times the rate of construction workers.

Beyond crashes, the street carries a second danger: enforcement. For a largely immigrant workforce, an ordinary traffic stop can expose an undocumented worker to federal immigration agents. After Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents raided Canal Street in late 2025, Los Deliveristas Unidos and the Street Vendor Project rallied together, and their pressure helped push the city to end an Adams-era practice of issuing criminal summonses for minor cycling violations in March 2026.

Months later, after a 17-year-old riding an illegal e-bike in Lower Manhattan was struck and killed by an SUV driver, the City Council took up a package of 17 e-bike bills and the mayor sent cease-and-desist orders to 42 online retailers selling machines his transportation commissioner called motorcycles marketed as bicycles. City officials say they are aiming at online retailers rather than the riders. Worker advocates counter that enforcement, whatever its stated target, tends to fall on the immigrant workers already most exposed to it.

If bike lanes are accommodating more deliveristas, they should also be protecting them. This year workers organized and co-designed the nation’s first Deliverista Hub at City Hall Park, with charging, rest space, and a bathroom. At the moment, the city has not committed to including more of these necessary hubs in the next Streets Plan.

Whose Curb Is It Anyway?

For Councilmember Gale Brewer (Manhattan’s 6th), who has sponsored numerous bills covering delivery workers, including the city’s bike-parking law (Local Law No. 111 of 2026) and two bills in the Council’s recent August 4th package, the increasingly challenging part about the streetscape and bike lanes is moving goods: “The parking is the easy part,” she said, “the moving of them is the hard part.” Local Law 111 requires DOT to install 5,000 bicycle parking stations over five years and to consider food-delivery-service data when citing them.

One of Brewer’s August bills, Intro 78, would require third-party delivery apps to submit data on their workers’ ID numbers, delivery times, and locations. She says that information would show the city where infrastructure investment is needed most.

Brewer described a street trying to accommodate everything at once: scooters, mopeds, e-bikes, pedal bikes, pedestrians, cargo bikes, cars, and eighteen-wheelers that set out cones and use the sidewalk as storage because their warehouses have no room. “It causes havoc,” she added. When asked whether the DOT had a handle on it, the councilmember was direct: “It has not been figured out. Lots of discussion, but it has not been figured out.”

Mohamed Attia, Managing Director of the Street Vendor Project (SVP), who also works in coalition with the Workers Justice Project, hears from vendors examples of protected bike-lane designs that can cut food access at the curb. When a lane runs between a parked food truck and the sidewalk, the truck may still be legally parked, but its customers are now on the other side of moving bike and e-bike traffic. To order, pay, or pick up food, they have to step into or across the lane. That turns the bike lane into a barrier between the vendor and the sidewalk, a conflict that played out over a lane on 31st Street in Astoria with the King Souvlaki food truck. Vendors sell fresh, affordable food in neighborhoods all over the city, and every new use of the curb, from outdoor dining to giant planters to delivery staging, leaves them less room to do it. That pressure helps explain why expanding bike lanes remains controversial in some neighborhoods: the fight is over who gets to use the curb, who loses space, and whether food access is planned into the redesign.

Whitney McGuire, a sustainability strategist and Founder and Managing Partner of The McGuire Consulting Group, sees bike lanes as one visible piece of a much larger system linking labor, infrastructure, and convenience. The bike lane, she said, is “where these sort of different worlds converge,” between delivery drivers and the tourists and residents who want another way to move through the city. “The safety concerns are the same. But who gets prioritized in these conversations? What is [the] city investing into this infrastructure?” She has tracked the sector’s wage increases, restroom availability, and new hubs, and from her vantage “as an observer and also as a consumer,” it “still remains kind of lawless, wild, wild west out there.” For consumers, ordering a meal feels almost effortless; the costs of that ease are absorbed by the workers moving through bike lanes and by the streets that must accommodate them.

Who Gets Written Off?

Advocates and researchers have documented how app-based grocery and restaurant delivery has rapidly expanded since 2021, reshaping a workforce that once consisted largely of neighborhood delivery employees into tens of thousands of independent contractors. The same New Yorkers who expect a hot meal in thirty minutes may also be the ones who complain when a delivery worker rides against traffic or briefly uses the sidewalk. While it can appear that workers alone set the pace, their speed is heavily influenced by app design, customer expectations, and algorithmic penalties that reward faster deliveries and punish delays, creating pressures that can push workers to bend rules and then shoulder the blame.

Bike lanes also have limits that planners and advocates often skip. “It’s never going to be fully, entirely a bicycle city, because of commerce,” said Richard Mullings, chair of Queens Community Board 3, who spoke in his individual capacity. The board has not taken a formal position on the next Streets Plan. He pointed to the need for designated loading and unloading areas for vans and trucks as well as to residents who need cars for a hospital trip, severe weather, or family care. A redesign that treats the bike as the default and plans around everyone else risks writing off New Yorkers who cannot use one: the wheelchair user who needs the curb and the loading zone, the older resident for whom a bike is not an option, the person who keeps a car to carry a family member who cannot ride. A food-infrastructure-forward plan has to widen access rather than narrow it.

For Transportation Alternatives (TA), the city’s most influential street-safety organization, the cargo bike is one way to reduce street congestion. Alexa Sledge, their Senior Director of Communications and Strategy, argues that bike lanes in New York were never intended for recreation and that riders have always been disproportionately lower-income and people of color. The vehicle most likely to kill a cyclist, she notes, is a truck. In a report co-authored with LDU, the group called for wider lanes, protected intersections, and charging stations for delivery workers. Both Nathaniel and Mullings recall recent meetings where TA presented their visions for car-free neighborhoods to community boards. Those plans ran headlong into familiar anxieties about parking loss, small business survival, and whether these safer streets were truly being designed with existing residents in mind.

They also surfaced dynamics around race and gentrification, as longtime Black and brown residents questioned whether “safer streets” had become shorthand for making their neighborhoods more palatable to wealthier, whiter newcomers rather than truly responsive to their own mobility and safety needs. As Nathaniel put it, “At the end of the day, people still vote for the lanes, even after arguing tooth and nail about how frustrated they are. Folks know the lanes are good; it’s the way they’re being presented that’s creating all the tension.”

Who Gets a Say?

The city has yet to build an inclusive process for the people who use bike lanes the most. The Streets Plan is binding, yet the law says nothing about consulting the public on the streets they use every day. Local Law 195 obligates the DOT to run a public education campaign about the plan once it exists, but it does not require hearings, comment periods, or any formal way for New Yorkers to advocate for a plan they will later be required to follow. A Streets Plan cannot be for the people if the people are only educated about it after consultants and government officials have already decided what the streets are for.

The consultation that does happen comes project by project, and it often runs inconsistently. Mullings says the DOT builds first and tells his board after: “It’s like someone going to your house and starting to do renovations and saying, oh, by the way, I’m doing renovations at your house.”

“Our primary purpose is to ensure that all the voices are heard,” he adds, that “everyone has a say, whoever’s impacted by this.” Mullings continued, “DOT has been working in a different order where they’re actually just executing and then letting us know after,” which he views as “completely wrong” and “improper.” Nathaniel sees the agency arrive either when an idea is barely formed or when it is already finished, with the stretch in between, when public input could still change the plan, left out.

The people most absent from that process are the deliveristas who, as LDU has argued, use the bike lane as a job site. Nathaniel says his board “…membership is overwhelmingly black… predominantly older, multigenerational households that have been here for a good amount of time… some of them are homeowners.” In his experience, “you see a lot of parents with kids on the back of their bike that tend to be white, that are commuting to school, young professionals again, that tend to be white, that might be going up Bedford,” and deliveristas who are, “Latinx, sometimes African, that… certainly don’t necessarily live in the neighborhood.” This observation reveals the myth built into many bike-lane fights, that the lane is often treated as a symbol of white leisure or neighborhood change, but it is also where immigrant delivery workers carry food for an app economy whose customers are often insulated from the labor and street conflict that make their convenience possible.

The result is a street decided by one group of New Yorkers, resisted by another, and worked by a third. “For too long, delivery workers have been expected to keep the city running without having a voice in how the streets they depend on are designed,” Montero said. Additionally, “…if delivery workers are considered essential, then the infrastructure that makes their work possible has to be treated as essential too. Streets should be planned not only for moving vehicles, but for protecting the workers who keep New York running.” A more inclusive Streets Plan would not erase neighborhood concerns; it would give residents, vendors, and deliveristas a way to decide together whether a street should function as a neighborhood, a workplace, a delivery corridor, or all three.

What Could a Food Infrastructure-Forward Streets Plan Do?

These interviews point toward a Streets Plan that starts from the lived reality of the streetscape, not from an outdated assumption that bike lanes are only for recreation or low-cost transportation. A food-infrastructure-forward plan would commit to the following:

  • Count what the bike lane contributes. The plan should measure the bike lane as freight and food infrastructure, tracking commercial volume the way the city already tracks bike trips. A 2025 study by MIT researcher Jake Boeri, who classified 9,629 vehicles at five bike-count sites, found that motorized vehicles make up roughly three-quarters of the traffic in protected bike lanes, that e-bikes alone account for nearly two-thirds of all vehicles observed, and that nearly a quarter were commercial. Design decisions should rest on that reality, not on the idea that the lane is used only for leisure.
  • Plan the curb so food access and freight can coexist. Loading zones, vendor space, and delivery staging should be designed together, so a protected lane stops severing vendors from customers and a delivery truck stops parking on the sidewalk or obstructing the bike lane.
  • Bring the lane’s users into the room. Delivery workers, vendors, and residents should help shape and evaluate street projects, so a binding Streets Plan reflects the people who navigate it every day. In a written statement from Montero, LDU called for protected routes, secure e-bike parking, public charging, Deliverista Hubs, privacy-protective delivery data, and an ongoing role for worker organizations in planning and evaluation.
  • Protect workers from surveillance while using data responsibly. For LDU, Brewer’s data bill, Intro 78, could be misused as written, because it would collect GPS routes tied to individual workers who already face heavy tracking from apps. The plan should rely on combined, de-identified activity data with clear privacy limits, and leave individual monitoring out.
  • Make the platforms pay for the infrastructure they profit from. Uber Eats, DoorDash, Grubhub, Amazon, and other delivery companies route food through public infrastructure they do not fund or maintain. New York has already debated surcharges and fee structures for delivery, transit, and freight; the missing piece is a comparable tool for the bike lanes, hubs, charging stations, and workers that make the last mile possible. A platform fee should be directed into the infrastructure these companies rely on and kept off workers’ time and money.

Bike lanes are now a permanent part of how New York feeds itself. The Streets Plan due this fall should recognize that reality plainly: the city must design, fund, and govern bike lanes as food, labor, and transportation infrastructure. The food is already moving through these lanes. The workforce is already using them as a workplace. Now the city needs a Streets Plan that treats both as essential.

David DeVaughn grounds his coaching and strategy work in a simple conviction: that leaders who are most burdened by inequity deserve the most rigorous, caring, and honest support available. As Founder and Managing Principal of StrivEquity Consulting LLC, he works at the intersection of personal transformation and institutional change, coaching and strategy with leaders who seek to close the gap between who they are and how they lead. Through the Equity-Responsive Leadership (ERL) model, David centers identity, power, and accountability as the operating logic of effective leadership. His strategy practice spans city government, public health, philanthropy, and national nonprofits, where he has consistently helped teams move from compliance to genuine cultural responsiveness. David is an ICF Professional Certified Coach (PCC), an NYC & NYS MBE-certified firm founder, and a National Urban Fellow with nearly 20 years of experience across policy, workforce development, and equity-centered capacity building.

Credits – nycfoodpolicy

Cover image by by Brett Jordan on Unsplash.

More Blog Posts

Close-up of a geometric stone-and-brick mosaic surface with hexagon and triangle shapes filled with dark pebbles and rough brick.
1729789518813
1757942321736
Williams (1)